Sherri, a genealogist and friend from Topeka, inspired me today to repost this. One of her African American ancestors, who lived during the civil war era, has a military headstone but yet no records have been located to support his military participation.
Now there are many reasons for this, and it is impossible to list or address all of them. But three of the top ones are listed below:
- The headstone was placed in error, or by descendants based on family stories. This is a common. Even in Lyons Kansas my grandfather has a permanent WWI placard placed on his "resting place." Yet, he didn't serve one day in the military due to a physical deformity.
- Records are harder to obtain for African American soldiers who served with Confederate troops, and for ex-slaves prior to the Civil War. But might I add, not impossible.
- Many African Americans served under alias names (or changed their names) after serving, making tracing them more difficult.
Alias surnames and new given names were actually adopted, especially for slaves during the Civil War. The common belief is that the "surname" of slaves changed with new slave masters, but this actually should be taken as a possibility, but not a rule. During the Civil War, slaves were often substituted to serve for their master or an arrangement was made for them to serve for another. This was common practice for southerners to meet a requirement of military service and they could do it with as little as the promise of freedom upon return. If an agreement was made by the slave-master to "rent" out a slave to do military service for another often the slave used the surname for whom they were fighting during their military service of the Civil War. Sometimes, this was a temporary name change. As in the case of Nelson Strader, discussed below, many returned to their former master's name after the war. This was all possible because after the Civil War ex-slaves could choose whatever name they wanted.
After the Civil War
Nelson Strader fought for Mr. Mason, arranged by his master. (last para: "I was never married to the soldier only by slavery custom. I belonged to Fielding Vaughn of Green Co. Ky and my husband Nelson Strader belonged to Lewis Strader also of Gren Co. Ky. Both of our masters are now dead.")
And, others just chose a surname that they liked, as did Minor (Wair/Weir) Underwood. Minor was purchased by William Weir to take fight in his stead, and upon completion of the agreement and the end of the civil war, he embraced the name Underwood once he arrived in Kansas with the Exodusters. His original slave master was not Underwood, nor was he ever owned by an Underwood.
The details of an ex-slave's name change are most often found in Civil War pension records.